Stephen Howard Woodwind - Repairs, reviews, advice, tips and tales...
Haynes woodwind maintenance manuals
Glossary - explanations & clarifications
Haynes woodwind maintenance manuals
 

The Split E key

A question that's often asked by prospective flute players is " Should I get a flute with a split E? ".
This is often preceded by the question " Just what IS a split E? "

Have a look at the picture below...

Split E key

Two flutes - the upper without Split E, the lower with. All that's different is that on the Split E flute the G key has been divided up into two separate keys able to move independently but linked, so that when the G is pressed it brings down its twin.
There's also a link to the G's twin from the low E.

The Split E really comes into use on the top E. The G key isn't used for top E, and normally both key cups would remain open, but with this link in place the lower of the two cups is brought down.

So what does it actually do??
Opinion is divided. In theory it gives you a cleaner, more responsive top E - and yet you'll see a great many professional range flutes without this feature fitted. That's because if a flute is built well enough it really doesn't need any help with the top E.

So it's more perhaps a feature of cheaper instruments. Then again, the standard of manufacturing in the budget instrument arena is much higher than it used to be - perhaps making the Split E unnecessary. If a flute gives you an iffy top E then nine times out of ten it's more than likely due to a dodgy head joint than a need for a Split E.
To be frank it's really not worth working up a sweat about. Most flute makers offer the same model with or without the Split E, the difference (on student instruments anyway) is ten or twenty pounds or so....nothing worth quibbling about - so if in doubt, get the Split E variant. If you're a player upgrading then you're the best equipped to decide whether you need this function or not. Try a Split E and a non-Split E model side by side and see if there's a difference.

There's also a mechanical drawback to the mechanism. Whenever keys are linked together in this fashion it becomes vital that there's no wear or free play on the keys (see the action test), which increases the likelihood of developing a leak. It also means there's more to go wrong.
The Split E mechanism requires careful regulation of both the link from the G to its twin key and the link from the E to the twin. It also makes the top E action slightly heavier.

Another option associated with the G and Split E keys is an 'inline G'.
The flutes pictured above both have what's known as an 'offset G'. Note the relationship of the G and Split E keys to the other keys - they're set slightly forward. On an 'inline' model these two keys would be in line with the surrounding keys.
As per the Split E debate, opinion is divided as to how beneficial or otherwise this might be - with the pro camp maintaining that it requires the player to adopt the 'correct' hand position, and the anti camp proposing that it forces the hand into an unnatural and strained position.

A more plausible explanation is that early flute makers needed to keep things as simple as possible, and placing the main tone holes in a straight line was the easiest option - and thus it became 'traditional', with all that that entails.
Once again, the only way to know for sure is to try both options side by side - but bear in mind that it can take some time to get used to the hand position either way and that players of closed hole offset G flutes may find that open hole inline G flutes take rather longer to get used to.

To sum up then: 20 or 30 years ago I'd have said that buying a student flute with a Split E was a good bet. These days it's not so clear cut - and if you're at all able to play the flute well enough to decide for yourself then that's exactly what you should do.

Copyright © Stephen Howard Woodwind 2015